Reserve Against Returns: How Royalty Reserves Work

Why Publishers Hold Reserves

Print books are sold to retailers on a returnable basis. A store that orders 50 copies and sells 30 can return the other 20 for credit, often months later. The publisher's sales report counts copies shipped, so the royalties on those 20 copies look earned when they are not.

Without a reserve, the publisher would pay royalties on the whole shipment and then have to claw them back when the returns arrive. A reserve against returns withholds a share of each period's print royalties instead, and pays it out once the returns window has closed.

How Holds and Releases Work

Take a contract with a 20% reserve on print royalties, released two periods after it is held. Assume no returns come in, so every hold is released in full.

In the first two periods the author gets 80% of what they earned. From period 3, releases from earlier holds start coming back, and in period 4 the author is paid more than the book earned that period. Each release belongs to a specific hold, which is why a statement should show when each held amount is due back, not only a single total.

Flat Percentage or Return-Rate Based

Most contracts use a flat percentage: 20% of print royalties, every period. It is easy to read, but it holds the same share whether the book is returned heavily or hardly at all.

A return-rate based reserve holds whatever share the book's actual return rate calls for, up to a cap. A title with 8% returns has 8% held, not 20%. It is fairer to authors of steady sellers and takes more tracking, because the rate has to be recalculated from real return data every period.

What to Check in a Contract

• A cap. “A reasonable reserve” with no number leaves the percentage to the publisher.
• A release date. Each hold should come back after a fixed number of periods.
• Print only. Digital formats are not returnable and should not be reserved.
• An end date. Returns fall off sharply after the first year or two. Some contracts stop reserving after a set number of months, or restart only for a new edition.

Reserves also slow advance recoupment. Held royalties are not earned yet, so they cannot pay down the advance until they are released.

How Familiar Handles Reserves

Each contributor on a book gets their own reserve policy in Familiar. You choose a flat percentage or a return-rate based reserve with a cap, which formats it applies to (all print formats by default), and how many months each hold lasts. Holds release in full when their time is up, and you can release one early or extend it. A policy can end at a set month or restart when a new edition comes out.

Statements include a reserve section with reserves currently held, the amount releasing this period, and the net after release, plus a line for each book showing what is held and the month it releases. Authors see exactly when their money is coming back.

Moving from another system? Enter reserves you are already holding as opening balances so they release on schedule. The royalty statement guide shows how the reserve section looks on a finished statement.

Frequently Asked Questions

Related Guides